Home / Editorial policy

Every number comes from the party that published it

Before an article is written, every figure that will appear in it goes into a register with four things recorded: the figure, the exact wording of the source, the link, and what kind of figure it is. That last one does most of the work, because the same number means different things depending on where it came from.

A published manufacturer specification is not the same as a minimum requirement in a code. A test threshold is not a working capacity. A breaking load is not a load you should put on a shelf. A retailer’s listing is not the manufacturer’s data sheet. A figure we worked out ourselves from two published numbers is ours, not theirs. Where it matters to what you buy, the article says which kind it is.

Each article ends with a note naming the sources it used and the date the figures were checked. If you find one that has moved, tell us through the contact page and we will check it and say so on the page.

We say when we could not find something

A lot of what gets repeated about home organization has no published source behind it. When we go looking and come up empty, we write that we found nothing, rather than filling the gap with a confident number.

That is why some of our articles say things like: we found no published standard for closet bin sizes, or we found no comparative testing of these materials against each other. Those sentences are the finding. They are more useful than a figure we would have had to invent, and they tell you to measure your own shelf instead of trusting a category.

We also avoid absolute claims about what no maker publishes or what no standard covers, because we cannot verify the absence of everything. We write what we looked for and did not find.

What decides a recommendation

We start from the measurement that rules a product out. A product that suits a deep cabinet is the wrong answer for a shallow one, however good it is, so we never call something the best without saying who it is best for and in what space.

We do not rank by review count. The number of reviews a product has mostly measures how long it has been listed and how much it has been advertised, and it tells you nothing about whether it fits your cabinet.

We do not accept payment for a recommendation, a placement, or a position in a comparison. No brand sees an article before it is published, and no brand can ask for a change after it is.

What this editorial policy means for a product recommendation

Three very different things get presented as a product recommendation online, and we keep them apart on the page so you know which one you are reading.

Tested. We had the product in a real home and used it. Where an article says tested, that happened, and it says in which space and for how long. We will never write that we tested something we did not.

Analyzed from published data. This is most of what we do, and we say so rather than imply more. We read the maker’s own specification, the assembly and safety sections of the listing, and the dimensions the seller publishes, then compare those figures to the measurement that decides whether the thing goes in. We did not have the product in our hands.

Illustrative. A photograph or a layout shown to explain a principle, not to recommend the exact item in it. Where an image is a concept rather than a real room, the caption says which it is, and we never present a generated image as proof of a real transformation.

On anything you fix to a wall or load with weight, we quote the maker’s own wording and name the section it sits in, rather than summarizing it in our own voice. Where a listing does not answer a safety question, we say which sections we read and what to ask the seller before you order. Customer reviews are reported as what buyers said, never as a specification.

How we are paid, and the line it does not cross

When a link on this site takes you to a retailer and you buy something, we may earn a commission. It never changes the price you pay. It is disclosed at the top of every article that carries such a link, above the content, rather than buried at the bottom or hidden behind a link to another page.

A commission never decides what we recommend, and it never decides which products get compared. Where the honest answer is that nothing in a category is worth buying, or that the thing you already own is fine, that is what the article says. Our affiliate disclosure has the full statement, and the best-of guides explain the comparison method in more detail.

Corrections

We get things wrong. When we do, we fix the page rather than quietly deleting it, and we change the checked date at the bottom of the article so you can see that something moved.

If you have measured something and our figure does not match, that is the most useful message we can get. Send it to us through the contact page with what you measured and what you measured it on.

Who writes this

Cozy & Tidy is published by Cultureweb SRL, a company registered in Belgium under VAT number BE 0897.075.794, at Rue Gérard 13-15, 7020 Nimy (Mons). The legal notice has the full details and the about page explains what the site is for.